Articles Of Confederation Flaws

The Articles of Confederation could also be determined ineffective. They did not provide a president, any kind of executive agency, or judiciary and they did not have any kind of tax base or way to pay off state and national debts. Document A shows how ineffective the government was because it was unable to impose taxation due to a very small minority. Rhode Island rejected the tax so the government decided not to put it into effect. If taxes had been put in place, some of the state and national debts may have been able to be paid off. Without a strong leader, basic things like taxes cannot be imposed, which is why the Articles were so ineffective. They did not provide a way for the states to be controlled.

The Virginia Plan was favored by the big states. It envisioned a bicameral legislature with both houses having membership proportional to population. The New Jersey plan was favored by the small states. It called for each state's representation in each house to be equal to every other states. The delegates considered whether the legislature should be elected directly by the people or by the state legislatures. The usual arguments against allowing

The Articles of Confederation was an ineffective government, failing both externally and internally due to a weak central government. Externally, other nations refused to trade with America and disputed over territorial gain. Internally, the Articles of Confederation had little distinct power over the states, forcing a split into differing political parties and social stratification. With a lack of both external and internal control, the negative aspects of the Articles of Confederation prompted the nation to adopt the Constitution.

The Articles of Confederation failed because it was created for the wrong reason with weak central government. The reason for creating the Articles of Confederation because of the states jealousy of their own power. They also made the confederation to established a system in which each state can retain almost all of it’s own power to do what it wanted. It had no independent source of power for it’s operations. According to the Keeping the Republic textbook, The Articles were replaced because it didn’t have a strong central government. Without a strong central government they were not able to provide the economic and political stability that the founders wanted. With the confederation they lack power and money. Having an unbalanced power in the government and the state federal

The Articles of Confederation was the United State’s first constitution, it was written in an effort to unite the states after the American Revolution and served as a blueprint for the modern constitution. In order for the Articles to become official, they had to be approved by all thirteen colonies. Although Congress sent the Articles of Confederation to the states around the end of 1777 to become ratified, they were not officially adopted until March 1, 1781. Under these Articles, the states remained sovereign and independent, with Congress serving as the last resort on appeal of disputes. The American people feared a strong national government and as a result of this, the Articles of Confederation were specifically designed to be weak in the sense that each state maintains its own sovereignty and all rights to govern themselves, with the except of the rights exclusively granted to Congress. Since the Articles lacked many necessary components to keep a nation properly structured, they were eventually revised into the constitution we recognize today. Although, the Articles of Confederation seemed as though it only contained weaknesses, within the document, many strengths and accomplishments were made. Overall, the Articles of Confederation were proven to be both efficient and non-efficient during the time period they were in effect.

After the grueling entrapment caused by the British, the American people pushed for a weaker federal government. With that, came the creation of The Articles of Confederation, a failed attempt at a perfect system. Under the laws set by The Articles of Confederation, the government could not tax or raise an army among many other problems. After this misstep, the nation was in need of a more capable form of government. Because The Articles of Confederation was inadequate, it caused many problems. After realizing this, American leaders meet at the Constitutional Convention to fix their mistakes, this led to the making of the Constitution. Two weaknesses of The Articles of Confederation were that they could not tax nor enforce taxes, there was

he Articles of Confederation created a government that gave the states too much power. The former colonies were afraid to make a government as strong as England's Parliament.The states had more power than the Federal Government. The Congress created by the Articles could not Enforce Treaties and couldn't collect taxes from the states. Not being able to collect taxes made it difficult to pay the soldiers when they were fighting in the Revolutionary War. Other weaknesses of the government created under the Articles deal with the states having more power than the Federal Government. There were no Federal Courts or Executive. States didn't have to follow or enforce Federal Laws. States even made their own money. The money would caused problems

On March 1st, 1781, the Articles of Confederation were signed and ratified. Although this document protected and strengthened the United States from British rule, gave the U.S citizens freedom, and organized the 13 states, there were many flaws which sat upon the surface of these articles. Over time these flaws presented themselves through high taxes, debt, and unenforceable laws across state line. Under the Articles of Confederation, there were neither a chief executive or a judiciary. In the ‘Federalists Papers’ it states that “The Crowning defect of the Confederation is the lack of a judicial power. Laws are pointless without courts to interpret and define their true meaning and operation.” Though it could make treaties, it could not enforce

One major flaw of the Articles of Confederation was that Congress was not granted the power to collect taxes from the citizens. Without having the power to levy and collect tax, Congress depended on the states to pay their assigned tax quotas voluntarily. The estimated amount of taxes to collected from the states every was not collected. The United States struggled to pay off debts and, without the power to collect taxes, Congress only had two alternatives for paying the debts and loans back: print more money or obtain loans to meet the deficient (Office of the Historian, para. 2). Congress decided to print more money, which led to inflation. The problem of inflation and the struggle of paying off debts monthly/annually were relatively reduced

In 1775, America began one of the most important moments of its life as well as history overall, the America Revolution. This war was fought to free the new colonies from the tyranny of the British monarchy and the unfair way it treated them. The fight was long and hard, but in the end the battle was won and the colonies became their own nation, left to rule under their own circumstances and set up their own government. Ironically when it came to setting this up, was in some ways, more difficult than the physical battle that came and went. The first attempt at a government blueprint came as “The Articles of confederation” which was the first written constitution and attempted to unify America under a set of rules that the citizens would better follow and appreciate. Martin Kelley quotes it as a creation of a “confederation of states whereby each state retained "its sovereignty, freedom, and independence, and every power, jurisdiction, and right . . . not . . . expressly delegated to the United States in Congress assembled." (Kelley). The failure came from its creation of independent states and as Ted Brackemyer puts it “…the lack of a strong national government in the Articles of Confederation led to three broad limitations.” These limits were economic disorganization, lack of central leadership, and legislative inefficiencies (Brackemyer).

The Virginia plan and the new jersey plan were plans on how many representatives a state received when voting. The Virginia plan proposed representation by the state's population and proposed an upper chamber to be elected by the lower chamber. With Virginia being one of the states with the highest population they would receive most of the power to govern the country over smaller states which would mean their state’s interest would overpower interest of smaller population states. Many other smaller states disagreed with this plan as they saw it as unfair and thought the needs and views of their state would be ignored.

The primary weakness of the Articles was that congress didn’t have much authority, This meant that congress couldn’t solve even the simplest problems. For example, if there was a dispute over whether someone was being scammed or not. Congress would not be able to get in between and settle the problem. Furthermore, another weakness of the articles was that Congress couldn’t impose taxes on the citizens. This led America’s currency to depreciate and no longer be as widely used. Additionally, the Articles were weak because it was difficult to pass laws. To pass a law, 9 out of the 13 states had to agree! Also, not only laws were hard to pass, but accepting a new state was difficult. To add a new state, all of the current states must agree to the proposal! There were severe flaws in the Articles of Confederation which led Edmund Randolph to propose the creation of a new

After the U.S. gained independence from G.B., they followed their first constitution. It was called the Articles of Confederation. Many people did not agree with the constitution. They did not like that every state was equal and got one vote. Northern states and Southern states had different human and geographic features. The Northern states had a larger population and so they did not like the rule that every state got one vote. Populated states wanted representation to be based upon population. However this lead to another debate on whether we should count slaves as part of a state’s population. Overall, states were fighting over who had power in the government.

One of the main problems within the Articles of Confederation was the fact that it purposefully established a weak central government. This was done for the sole reasoning that it was a belief among the common people that a strong national government would abuse

After the thirteen colonies officially gained their independence from Great Britain in 1783, they had looked forward confidently to reaping the benefits of independence, but were to discover that creating a nation was, if anything, a more arduous task than winning a revolution. Their existing constitution, the Articles of Confederation, adopted in 1781 by the Second Continental Congress, proved to be ineffective as the newly built nation was starting to crumble under its government. The weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation necessitated the ratification of a stronger and more effective constitution: the U.S. Constitution. An effective Constitution consists of a strong limited government with a separation of powers among the branches