preview

Critical Thinking

Good Essays

Assignment 1 - Critical Thinking University of Maryland University College Assignment 1 - Critical Thinking The Purpose of this paper is to apply the 10 steps developed by (Browne & Keeley, 2010) and I will apply those methods on the following memo. A memo was drafted by Ms. Mary Ford (personal communication, January 30, 2012) who is Director of Amalgamated Public Employees Union (APEU) Local No. 121 to Mr. Hector Fuentes the President of APEU Local No. 121 on the issue on New Mexico State Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) Outsourcing, proposed by the New Mexico Governor Gloria Gainor. This is response memo to the Governor’s (personal communication, October 20, 2011) letter informing the APEU Local No. 121 the intent to …show more content…

The value in the memo is that privatization of public services considered as “anti-American” as well as “assault on our unions” that protect the union workers. The author who is being with the union and author’s value assumptions is debatable. Author was biased to the union and expressed author’s point of view based on work experience as well as personal events that happened to author’s family members in the past. In the statement, the author believes that Governor’s action was going to affect not only to their current APEU union members but the whole America due to privatization. There is no clear demonstration or fact that privatization was “anti-American” and in some cases the privatization of public services helped the state with more money and the public service rendered efficiently and professionally (Kittower, 2007). In the memo outsourcing agents will accept lower wages than the current state employee wages, this will further lead to governors think to reduce the wages of all other state departments in the future. The author’s brother-in-law lost the job during the similar proposal of the outsourcing, and author strongly assumes that the governor’s proposal will have some of the union members lose their jobs, as well as reduction of the state government employee salary

Get Access