preview

In Response To Executive Order 906 By Sandra Cisneros Analysis

Satisfactory Essays

In the poem “In Response to Executive Order 9066: All Americans of Japanese Descent Must Report to Relocation Centers” , by Dwight Okita, a young Japanese-American girl gives us her point of view on being the race she is at the time. She expirienced recism, at it's finest, and endured it like a champ. In the short story "Merican's," by Sandra Cisneros, a young Mexican-American girl gives us her experience growing up in an American household with a Hispanic grandmother that detested Americans. Both works show that cultural heritage and physical appearances do not determine what it means to be American.

In "In Response to Executive order 9066" the little girl talks about how she doesn't even like traditional Japanese things, and prefers foods like hot dogs. Her best friend in school stops liking her …show more content…

Her and her two brothers wait outside of church for their grandmother one day, while she is praying, and at the end of she story the grandmother asks two "typical" Americans to take their picture, and asks them in English, and the litter girl is astonished that her grandmother even speaks English, because she always spoke to the kids in Spanish. The grandmother calls Americans barbaric, implying her distaste for America. The little girl, despite being brought up by her "Merican" hating grandmother feels as though she IS an American.

Both Authors consider themselves Americans, but in Okita's poem it is discussed more about learning new cultures, and learning where you fit in. She is a very strong willed girl that doesn't believe she has done anything wrong, jsut because her family tree starts in Japan. Cisneros' short story talks more about how, although her family is from mexico she still considers herself an American. Both talk about cultural backgrounds, and unfair assumptions based on race, and what it really means to be an

Get Access