preview

Mr Vs Lycan

Decent Essays

Intense developmental stages in technology have brought us into a place we never thought we would be in, where instances of computers can function correspondingly to us humans. These machines can perform acts such as playing chess and sorting mail, which are actions that most of us have done before. Both William G. Lycan and John R. Serle assess this topic, using different thought experiments, but both introduce the term Artificial Intelligence. Both philosopher’s objectives are not to argue whether this is possible but how will we distinguish humans from computers. Lycan provides us a distinct definition of Artificial Intelligence as being “the science of getting machines to perform jobs that normally require intelligence and judgement.” (Lycan, p.350) The argument …show more content…

We are then faced with determining what freedom actually is, which varies between individuals. Lycan states “I think that to have freedom of choice in acting is (roughly) for one’s action to proceed out of one’s own desires, deliberation, will and intention, rather than being compelled or coerced by external forces regardless of my desires or will.” (Lycan, p. 354) Lycan argues that in the cases of Harry and Henrietta, they do have freedom of choice because of two reasons: Harry can have unforeseen actions akin to humans and his performance is carried out by his intellectual structures. Serle begins his argument very similarly to Lycan, but instead of defining AI, he uses the terms strong and weak to determine AI. Serle says “According to weak AI, the principle value of the computer in the study of the mind is that it gives us a very powerful tool.” (Serle, p. 344) In turn, Serle says “according to strong AI, the computer is not merely a tool in the study of the mind; rather the appropriately programmed computer really is a mind, in the sense that computers are given the right programs can be literally said to understand and have other

Get Access