War Is Not The Answer War is never the answer. People can never get anything out of it because in the end, there is just going to be more chaos. In the book, My Brother Sam Is Dead by James and Christopher Collier, a lot of the hard times for the American Revolution are presented with the Meeker Family. The main characters are Sam and Tim Meeker along with the supporting characters, Mr. and Mrs. Meeker. In My Brother Sam Is Dead, both sides of war are shown, author's Collier and Collier ultimately argue that war is not going to achieve anything.
The way war can affect something is the division in families. In My Brother Sam Is Dead, Father kicks out Sam because he would want him to go to school than go to war with a chance of death. “Go, Sam. Go. Get out of my sight. I can’t bear to look at you anymore with that vile costume. Get out. And don’t come back until you come dressed up as my son, not as a stranger.” (Collier and Collier 21) These were some of the hardest words you can ever here but this is
…show more content…
In the book, My Brother Sam Is Dead, Sam is trying to fight for freedom for the patriots. "You don't understand, Father, you just don't understand. If they won't let us free, we have to fight. Why should they get rich off of our taxes back in England? They're 3000 miles away, how can they make laws for us? They have no idea of how things are here." This is a good example because Sam is trying to fight for freedom as a principle but in reality he could not come home and never see his family ever again. The book also shows the beheading of Ned. "The sword flashed in a bright arc, the fastest thing I ever saw move. Ned's head jumped off his body and popped into the air." It's very sad but the principle is that he was going to do die but in reality he is black and the white people don't treat them right. These was a really good example from the book and probably the best for the idea of going against the
In the novel, My Brother Sam is Dead, Father says, “Is it worth war to save a few pence in taxes?” (Collier and Collier 21). This quote summarizes the main idea of that war does nothing. My Brother Sam is Dead is written by James and Christopher Collier. The authors introduce many strong characters that include Sam, Tim, Life, and Susannah Meeker and takes place during the American Revolutionary War. The authors, Collier and Collier, try to prove that war does not help by adding the theme inside of a realistic plot that involves family and death, something everyone has or has gone through in their life. By adding family and death, it makes readers connect the story to our life and makes the reader question if war is actually worth it if the
The war brings enormous damages to humanity. People who survive war suffer from psychological problems. In the excerpt from, A Long Way Gone, a boy who managed to stay alive through war suffers from the past memories that are even in his dreams, “I was afraid to fall asleep, but staying awake also brought back painful memories. Memories I sometimes wish I could wash away” (Beah). This quote makes it clear that people who went through war suffer mentally from unwillingly dreaming of war and memories that suddenly come to their heads. The image “In Times of War” also shows that humanity suffers from war. In the cartoon picture, there are people lying
“Look at Europe, they’ve had one war after another for hundreds of years, and show me where anything ever got any better for them.” In My Brother Sam is Dead the authors use the war as a way to hint at the readers that they are against war. They also use Tim as the narrator to show how it is on both sides of the war. The authors (Collier and Collier) look at war like it’s their arch enemy.
Wars are often glorified in tone to give praise and respect for those on the battlefields. There is an overall understanding that there are sacrifices needed in order to accomplish a larger goal. Excluded from this understanding is the realization that the effects of war
War leads to oppression and leaves negative implications on all people and societies by impacting the poor, women, children, and nations as a whole. "War is a state of violent conflict between one or more groups" (Rasenberger 3). Rasenberger defines war as a state of conflict between one group within itself or several groups in combat with each other, what is not mentioned are the after-effects of war. War itself leads to many civilian and military deaths, an estimated 1.5-3.8 million people died during the Vietnam War and an approximate 500,000 people died in the Iraq war. The biggest tragedy of War is that it always results in fatality, but another key, negative, factor to understand is that after the War many adverse implications arise. Post-war ramifications in the nation fall upon the poor, women, and children, making them weaker and less motivated leading to the downfall of a society. Regardless if a nation wins or is defeated in war they have to deal with consequences of war and find solutions to the impacted people and society. It is essential to understand that there is never a true victor in war because regardless of the outcome, fatality and a fall of morale within society on both sides are inevitable. War has often been the solution to situations that required force or violence, but in recent times this has
When people talk about war it tends to be a sore subject. Although I stated what I thought on the outlook of how the war tells the story of those whose lives were lost in it the outlook on war can vary an unlimited amount. My first reasoning on my argument is that war consumes those involved. By involved I mean anyone who has been directly
War. It can either make a nation or break one. The people who have died in war to achieve their principles of freedom are the foundation of almost every great country. Legendary places, nations, and homes are the outgrowth of fruitful wars that have been fought by people wanting to end injustice. Even though war can end successfully with freedom and justice, it can also end with brutality and loss of life. In a lot of wars, fights have been fought and lives have been lost without the wanted outcome. In My Brother Sam is Dead, the Collier brothers have shown war’s injustice and brutality as well as the accomplishment of one’s principle. The passings of Jerry Sanford, Tim’s father(Life), and his brother, Sam Meeker, induced Tim’s decision of war to be neutral.
“I do not know with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones” ~ Albert Einstein. War can have drastic effects on everyone that encounters it’s destructive nature, although some might be affected differently than others, or more noticeably, everyone is still affected nonetheless.Both Elie Wiesel and Ishmael Beah survived devastating wars and were changed, both mentally and physically forever.
Walter Dean Myers touches on a subject that give thought to war in general in his book Sunrise Over Fallujah. Sunrise Over Fallujah focuses on the Iraq war after 9/11 and a young man’s experiences while there. The Historical significance of sunrise Over Fallujah is that the young man, Robin “Birdy” Perry, realizes shortly after arriving in Iraq that this war will not end quickly, and that he doesn’t even really understand why he is there, or why his country, for that matter is there. There is a lot from Sunrise Over Fallujah that relates to real life occurrences and thoughts in and about the war in Iraq.
A small family of four, living in the Tory town of Redding. Life was great Mr. and Mrs. Meeker owned a small tavern that supplies their town with food, rum, and supplies. Their son Timmy helped around the tavern and did chores, because his older brother Sam was off at college. Everyone in Redding was close and knew the Meeker family, they all admired how they had raised Sam and Timmy. Every year after college was over, Sam would come home and visit, except one.
My Brother Sam is Dead tells the story of 14 year old Tim Meeker in the time of the American Revolutionary War. It mainly speaks of social, financial, and emotional pressures of the rebel families, including his own. Not only is this a thrilling narrative, but it is also educational and leads one ask questions about international opinions, national economics, and historical events connected to the book. The son of a couple that lives in Redding, Connecticut, commonly known as a “Tory” town, Tim Meeker helps his parents operate the tavern they own and, like any younger brother, looks up to his older brother, Sam.
The first way the authors argue against war is that war tears families apart. In the book, Sam and Father do not get along. Father is against war while Sam goes to fight for the Patriots. “You may know principle, Sam, but I know war” (Collier Collier 21). The quote argues that both Sam and Father have different points of views on war. Sam tells his little brother that he is going to take the
My Brother Sam Is Dead is based on a young man and his family. Tim big brother named Sam went into the war between the Loyalist and the Patriots. During the war Sam’s father disagreed for him to go into the war as a soldier of the Patriots because he told Sam that he could either be a tory or get out of the house. When Sam enlisted to be part of the Patriots, the Patriots side wasn’t doing so good as the Loyalist due to the lack of food supply, some of the soldier was man who was under 18 and were beginners, the cold weather and bad clothing, and the lack supplies of transportation.
Ha and her family in the book Inside Out and Back Again and the children in the article Children of War both have experience many challenges. One of these challenges is how the war affected them. During Kim Ha´s adventure, Ha and her family have a war on their doorstep. Ha wants the war to end as Ha said ¨Maybe soldiers will no longer patrol our neighborhood.¨(Lai 4). Since before the war, she probably could go to school without danger. Emir is also being affected in the war since she states that ¨After the war started, you could not even go out of your house.¨(Brice) It may be a small effect, but it is safer than losing your life. After they escape, they needed to adapt their surroundings and knowledge as Ha said¨Mother starts sewing in a
War always has an effect on the culture of a population. With a whole world going to war every nation sees the effects of this man made pass time. Like a chain effect, technology shapes and changes the way war is made. Thus changing the way war affects people. New technologies will be discussed and the way it changed warfare. As well as the way it affects us as an intelligent species. War molds whole cultures and changes the way we go about our business.