preview

Professionalism as It Relates to the Role of the Teacher in the Pcet Sector

Best Essays

II. Demonstrate a critical awareness of the concept of professionalism as it relates to the current role of the teacher working in the PCET sector

As alluded to in the previous section, professionalism and what it is that technically constitutes a ‘profession’ as opposed to merely an occupation, and what it means to be ‘professional’ has long been in debate. Millerson (1964) compiled a list of characteristics that members of a ‘profession’ should have – these included skills based on theoretical knowledge, education and training, a code of professional conduct and a powerful professional organisation. On this basis, Avis (2006) contends that teachers have never been professionals, merely paid workers. He compares teaching with the …show more content…

In terms of status, Furedi’s (2002) culture of fear pervades the FE sector, fear of redundancy, fear of inspection, fear of not being able to cope with the increasing demands of a management culture (Shain, 1998) – not quite the high rewards of status.

The Marxist view of professional groups is that they are merely differing levels of servants to the rich and powerful, with higher professions reaping higher rewards for their direct services, a plastic surgeon for example earning much more than a general practitioner that serves the community, and teaching seen as a quasi professional, in that although not paid directly for their services they are upholding a system that benefits the rich (class handout). It could be said that this view is more of a reality than that of the functionalist, although it is likely that teachers do not think about themselves this way, but in fact are

gullible fools who will be (and are being) dispensed with now that their usefulness has passed (Wright and Bottery, 1997, p236).

Perhaps not dispensed with, but re-modelled “to provide no more than their technical expertise within managerial strategies and policies devised elsewhere” (op.cit, p235).

The Weberian view of professionals as self-interested (Parry and Parry) does not correspond with the humanistic and libertarian values of many teachers, certainly student teachers, who have been shown by Avis and Bathmaker (2004) to exhibit

Get Access