preview

Reading Response

Decent Essays

Reading Reflection Response As the American education system works to facilitate changes to improve the success of students, much attention has been given to the importance of reading instruction. The decline of reading scores across the country has called for researchers to investigate the reading process and decipher which methods best promote successful reading. Alan Kamhi (2009) stirred a variety of reactions after authoring The Case for the Narrow View of Reading, in which he argues that poor reading skills stem from the American education system combining word recognition and comprehension into a single unit, and from a lack of acquiring content knowledge in other academic areas. Kamhi argues that teaching instruction in reading should focus solely on word recognition while …show more content…

Catts argues that fixating solely upon decoding is not be the best option because while comprehension is dependent upon knowledge, it also a complex cognitive process that takes more than just knowledge to comprehend a text (2009). Looking at educational implications, Catts states that the education system should provide limited direct reading instruction while focusing on content area instruction with engaging activities that require active listening and participation (2009). Catts recommends that early reading materials and curriculum should be content-rich expository and narrative passages, with the introduction of reading comprehension strategies after students have learned to successfully decode texts. Looking at implications for speech-language pathology practice, Catts asserts that SLPs need to play a key role in working to early identify students at risk for developing reading disabilities; and then utilize dynamic assessment and response to intervention to monitor potential risk students. According to Catts, SLPs need to be aware of the need to for domain specific knowledge and complex processes included in reading and comprehension when

Get Access