preview

Ruhling Manufacturing Company Essay

Decent Essays

1. Why might negotiation be favored over competitive bidding in certain procurement situations?
Based on the textbook and my understanding, whenever there are negotiations between a procurer and a supplier regarding a competitive bidding, the first thing that might be favored is the scope of the project, meaning both will sit down and discuss the entire project prior the work begins. Meanwhile, during the negotiations, evaluation criteria should be clear, and stated and defined. As the evaluation is based on the criteria stated and the procurer can request or ask the supplier’s opinions on certain specifications and where things can be improved.

There are two characteristics to be considered when negotiating over competitive bidding: …show more content…

Ruhling can proceed with the bidding by meeting all specific criteria established to determine which best process will offer the lowest product pricing on motors products that meet the technical requirements, financial and operational capacity to perform on the contract, product performance specifications, and product warranties

c. What would you do if you were the decision-maker at Ruhling (don't sit on the fence)

If I am the decision maker at Ruhling, I would recommend that Ruhling conduct the negotiation in procurement situation because in competitive bidding, it may perform poorly when projects are complex. Furthermore, competitive bidding may stifle communication between buyers and sellers, preventing the buyer from utilizing the contractor’s expertise when designing the project.

3. Comment on the practice of dual sourcing when part of the requirement is produced internally. Relate this to the advantages and disadvantages of a 100 percent requirements contract. (i.e. develop both the pros and cons of dual sources and the pros and cons of requirements contracts).

Dual sourcing is used very often as quality control problems, giving the buyer additional power to product attributes that are difficult to specify in a contract. In addition, dual sourcing is used less often for systems procured under multiyear contracts, suggesting that competition and contractual completeness may be

Get Access