Concept explainers
Why might mitochondrial, Y chromosome, and autosomal DNA provide different perspectives on our evolutionary past
To analyze:
The reason for the relationship of mitochondria, Y chromosome, and autosomal DNA with different aspects of our evolutionary past, for example regarding our relationship with Neandertals.
Introduction:
The evolutionary relationships of closely related organisms show different evolutionary processes in a relatively short time that has been of interest to a biologist since a long time. The comparative study of phylogenies concluded from the DNA sequences with different inheritance patterns i.e. mitochondrial, autosomal, and X & Y chromosomal loci delivers best widespread conclusions of the evolutionary history.
Explanation of Solution
Mitochondria DNA: The first genetic evidence for an African origin of modern humans was analyzed from the study of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) polymorphism. The mtDNA specifically gives the genealogical history and evolutionary relationship of mammalian species.
The mtDNA are inherited maternally; they do not show any recombination of alleles; unlike the nuclear genome, some non-coding mtDNA can evolve quickly which leads to a variation in the mtDNA within closely related species. In mammals, the rate of mutation in mtDNA is higher than nuclear genomes i.e.
The regions around the Great Rift Valley of East Africa have been home to humans and hominin ancestors for at least 4 million years. The model of Human evolution called as RAO model (for recent African origin) proposes humans are evolved from a small African population. The RAO model suggests that modern humans arose approximately
Y chromosome: The Y chromosome sequence variation provides complementary mtDNA analysis. Y chromosome is strictly paternally inherited, and outside the pseudo-autosomal region, it does not show any recombination with other chromosomes. Y chromosome sequence is poor and provides very less sequence diversity. It has short tandem repeats (Y-STR) that can mutate rapidly about
According to the RAO model, more diversity is observed within African Y chromosome sequence than non-African sequences. As the mtDNA and Y chromosomes are strictly maternal and paternal, their haplotypes can be used to trace the migration patterns.
Autosomal DNA: The analysis of thousands of human genome sequences demonstrated that autosomal genetic diversity in African population is greater compared to the non-African population. Likewise, the study of Single nucleotide polymorphic DNA of worldwide sample population revealed the highest frequency of unique alleles in Africans compared to Non- Africans.
From all of these aspects, the mtDNA of Neandertals is different from the modern human, and it also does not show any inbreeding. The comparative nuclear genome sequences revealed that
The hybridization of Neandertals genome with modern human genome revealed that inbreeding took place after the migration of modern humans out of Africa. The other analysis also revealed that Neandertal DNA is unevenly distributed in the human genome; for example, no Neandertal DNA on the X chromosome, rather on autosomes, carries Neandertal DNA with precise distribution.
The comparative study of phylogenies concluded from the DNA sequences with different inheritance patterns i.e. mitochondrial, autosomal, and X & Y chromosomal loci, delivers best widespread conclusions of the evolutionary history.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter D Solutions
Genetic Analysis: An Integrated Approach (3rd Edition)
- If myoglobin is found in all chordates, urochordates, and cephalochordates, b-globin is found in all vertebrates, a-globin in all ostracoderm descendants, z-globin in all gnathostomes, e-globin in all viviparous mammals, and g-globin in all placental mammals, then the most ancient of these genes: must be epsilon-globin (e-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral marsupials must be myoglobin, found only in descendants of the chordates, urochordates, and cephalochordates must be gamma-globin (g-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral placentals must be zeta-globin (z-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral gnathostome fishes must be beta-globin (b-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral vertebratesarrow_forwardA fossil believed to be the most recent common ancestor between housecats and lions is radio-dated to about 11 million years ago (mya). An analysis of a neutral section of mitochondrial DNA in both species finds 15 DNA base pair differences between the two cats today. Meanwhile, an analysis of housecats and pumas shows 4 DNA base pair differences between them, which are believed to have diverged around 3 mya. Using this data, what is the best estimate of the time since divergence of housecats and lynx, which have 11 DNA base pair differences in this mitochondrial DNA region? 5 mya O6 mya O 7 mya O8 mya 9 myaarrow_forwardThe ancestor of cats was presumably homozygous for wild type at all of the described genes. What was the phenotype of this ancestral cat at each of these loci? 1)Dark grey with black mackerel stripes 2)Light grey female with dark grey mackerel stripes 3)Light brown male with chocolate tips 4)Black female with large white patches 5)Cream male with small white patches and orange mackerel stripes 6)A uniformly colored black catarrow_forward
- Some people think that many of our uniquely human traits arose by sexual selection. Over thousands of years, women attracted to charming, witty men perhaps prompted the development of human intellect beyond what was necessary for mere survival. Men attracted to women with juvenile features may have shifted the species as a whole to be less hairy and softer featured than any of our simian relatives. Can you think of a way to test these hypotheses?arrow_forwardWhich node, 1-8, represents the most recent common ancestor of the Gray Wolf and the Domestic dog? Which node represents the most recent common ancestor of the Domestic Dog and the Red Fox? Which node represents the most recent common ancestor of the Coyote and the Swift Fox? Which node represents the most recent common ancestor of the Maned wolf and the Gray wolf?arrow_forwardIf myoglobin is found in all chordates, urochordates, and cephalochordates, b-globin is found in all vertebrates, a-globin in all ostracoderm descendants, z-globin in all gnathostomes, e-globin in all viviparous mammals, and g-globin in all placental mammals, then the most recent globin gene must be: epsilon-globin (e-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral marsupials myoglobin, found only in descendants of the chordates, urochordates, and cephalochordates gamma-globin (g-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral placentals zeta-globin (z-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral gnathostome fishes beta-globin (b-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral vertebratesarrow_forward
- What is "homology"? What is BLAST and how is it used? What’s a major assumption when drawing evolutionary relationships between organisms based onDNA sequences?arrow_forwardWyckoff et al. (2000. Nature 403:304-309) have proposed that some human male reproductive-associated genes have evolved by natural selection and not by neutral evolution. Part of the DNA sequence results of their study is shown below. Which gene(s) did seem to evolve by natural selection? Note: dn = number of substitutions per non-synonymous (replacement) sites and ds = number of substitutions per synonymous (silent) sites. dn ds Acrosin-Trypsin 0.138 0.064 Protamine 1 0.133 0.046 SRY 0.055 0.090 Histone H1 (testicular) 0.055…arrow_forwardIf mutations such as those of the Ubx gene can drastically change morphology in a single step, why do most evolutionary biologists maintain that modification of existingtraits and the evolution of novel characters have generally proceeded by successive small steps?arrow_forward
- Geneticists study mitochondrial and Y-chromosome DNA to determine the ancestry of modern humans. Such studies have led to the emergence of mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosome Adam, whose features above are a far-cry from an artist's interpretation of the Biblical narrative. Their progeny came to have the range of physical features now described as racial differences. How has modern genomics contributed to the debate about the validity and definition of these hypothetical parents and their descendants? References:arrow_forwardCan you answer all the parts to this diagram Species 1 and 2 are sister species from which you’ve cloned related genes. On the gene tree on the top of the next page, use labels to answer the following questions: (a) Label the node that represents a gene duplication with “D,” (b) Label the nodes that represent speciation events with “S,” (c) Pick a pair of genes that are paralogs and label them both “P.” (d) Pick a pair of genes that are orthologs and label them both “O.”arrow_forwardIf myoglobin is found in all chordates, urochordates, and cephalochordates, b-globin is found in all vertebrates, a-globin in all ostracoderm descendants, z-globin in all gnathostomes, e-globin in all viviparous mammals, and d-globin in all eutherian mammals, then the most recent globin gene must be: myoglobin, found only in descendants of the chordates, urochordates, and cephalochordates zeta-globin (z-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral gnathostome fishes epsilon-globin (e-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral marsupials beta-globin (b-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral vertebrates delta-globin (g-globin), found only in descendants of the ancestral eutheriansarrow_forward
- Human Anatomy & Physiology (11th Edition)BiologyISBN:9780134580999Author:Elaine N. Marieb, Katja N. HoehnPublisher:PEARSONBiology 2eBiologyISBN:9781947172517Author:Matthew Douglas, Jung Choi, Mary Ann ClarkPublisher:OpenStaxAnatomy & PhysiologyBiologyISBN:9781259398629Author:McKinley, Michael P., O'loughlin, Valerie Dean, Bidle, Theresa StouterPublisher:Mcgraw Hill Education,
- Molecular Biology of the Cell (Sixth Edition)BiologyISBN:9780815344322Author:Bruce Alberts, Alexander D. Johnson, Julian Lewis, David Morgan, Martin Raff, Keith Roberts, Peter WalterPublisher:W. W. Norton & CompanyLaboratory Manual For Human Anatomy & PhysiologyBiologyISBN:9781260159363Author:Martin, Terry R., Prentice-craver, CynthiaPublisher:McGraw-Hill Publishing Co.Inquiry Into Life (16th Edition)BiologyISBN:9781260231700Author:Sylvia S. Mader, Michael WindelspechtPublisher:McGraw Hill Education