preview

Papacy Dbq

Decent Essays

Rulers opposed papal power because the canon laws that restricted things the rulers were allowed to do with churches within their kingdom. They would have to get approval from the pope before they did certain things. This forced them to have to make compromises where secular and religious claims coincide.
The papacy assumed so much power in the 1200 because it had gained loyalty from a great amount of people for practical purposes.With a lot of people showing loyalty and trust towards the Papacy, it was able to expands its power over Europe. Since the papacy was the most influential and advanced government during its time it had “legislative power, law courts, bureaucracy, formal procedures, written records and considerable incomes from fees, …show more content…

These two kings were fighting over land in modern southwestern France. The men both prepared to go to war with each other, so they both wanted the churches in their kingdoms to pay taxes to help fund for the war. However, according to the canon law they church didn’t have to pay taxes to the lay ruler, unless the lay ruler got approval from the pope to tax the church. Despite, knowing the rulers both kings taxed the churches from their kingdoms without papal authorization, thus testing the Papacy’s power. The clergy had to choose between the kings or the Pope. Although, the pope had to power to excommunicate any clergy that disobeyed him, he didn’t win the conflict. The French king Philip IV cut off the wealth from France that was sent to the Pope. This cut off a major amount of Boniface income, causing the pope to back down. Meaning the kings of England and France had the power to tax their clergy, no matter what the canon law …show more content…

The men forged papal powers insulting the French, so that people would go against the Pope. The people believed in these lies and grew angry with the Pope demanding he be tried before the church council. Nogaret went with a army to capture the pope, in which they were successful. They held him as prisoner for two day and tortured him before he was freed by locals. However, the pope died soon after he escaped from Nogaret. In the eyes of many Christians this may be seen as unacceptable because they are being violent. Especially, since it’s the pope they are inflicting harm upon. The one man who is closer to God than anyone

Get Access