a)
Explanation of Solution
Kant’s categorical imperative:
The Kant’s categorical imperative is desired by the philosopher “Immanuel Kant” and he defined as that an “imperative” is a something that a person have to do.
For example, suppose a person wants to stop for being a thirsty then he has to drink, so in that ways we can says it is an “imperative”. And this will also know as the categorical/direct imperative.
- According to the Kant’s categorical imperative, monitoring the physiology and computer behavior of employees is ethical until the employees are well aware of all the data that is to be collected and about them being monitored.
- The employer should also take care of the fact that the data collected is only used for the purposes as explained to employees.
- This act may turn into an unethical act if the employees are unaware of being monitored or for what purpose the collected data will be used.
Example:
If Richie was not of company’s monitoring policies then it will be initially considered as an unethical behavior, but Richie was provided with all the documents where he can read about it when he was hired and even his boss was open to Richie about it. Even the boss is okay with everyone knowing about them getting monitored. All this facts conclude that monitoring was ethical according to categorical imperative.
b)
Utilitarianism:
Explanation of Solution
Utilitarianism is nothing but a moral theory that states that the greatest act is the one that increases utility.
According to utilitarian perspective, the monitoring the employees is ethical as it reducing the insurance costs by improving the health of the employees. This is benefitting both the employer and the employees. In such cases there is a risk of hampering the privacy of the employees but it is considered as ethical as long as it is transparent.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 2 Solutions
Experiencing MIS
- The set of ethical principles that puts principles in terms of natural rights is: a. Rule-deontology b. Deontology c. Egoism d. Utilitarianism It's not a graded question dnt reject plzarrow_forwardThink about your top three moral principles. What is the strongest justification for these ideas? Think of a good counterargument to these beliefs. What distinguishes your defense as superior? (Remember that you must have a valid cause for believing that your justification is the strongest.)arrow_forwardIn the context of a comparative essay, examine the similarities and differences between the ethical system theory and the ethical reasoning framework.arrow_forward
- Think about the top three moral principles that are important to you. What do you believe to be the most convincing argument in support of these principles? Take into consideration an appropriate alternative to the logic behind these concepts. What distinguishes your justification from others'? (It is important to keep in mind that in order to think that your argument is the best, you need to have a solid cause for doing so!)arrow_forwardWorkable ethical theories: 1. - Kantianism 2. Act Utilitarianism 3. Rule Utilitarianism 4. Social Contract Theory Pick two theories from your list and describe two similarities and two differences between themarrow_forwardDISCUSSION QUESTIONS a. According to Kant's categorical imperative, is a deci- sion not to postpone ethical? b. According to utilitarianism, is a decision not to post- pone ethical? 6. Suppose Leslie learns you presented only your alterna- tive, and you two become archenemies. To the compa- ny's disadvantage, the two of you are never able to work together again. According to utilitarianism, does this outcome change the ethics of your behavior? 7. Suppose that instead of not presenting Leslie's alternative at all. you present it, but in a very negative light. You are honest when you focus the bulk of your description of it on disadvantages because that's what you believe. How- ever, you also know that Leslie does not agree with the way you see the situation. Given your biased presenta- tion, the committee selects your alternative. a. According to Kant's categorical imperative, is your 1. According to Kant's categorical imperative, is your action not to present Leslie's alternative…arrow_forward
- 13. Which of the following statements is true of the relativist position of ethics? a It holds that any cultural behavior can be judged only within the cultural context in which it occurs. b It encourages people to identify those rules that apply across cultures. c It argues that cultural differences are only superficial and that fundamental notions of right and wrong are universal. d It focuses particularly on identifying acts and conditions that most societies think of as wrong, such as murder and theft.arrow_forward4.What do we mean when we say an ethical theory is rational?arrow_forwardAccording to utilitarianism, is your action not to present Leslie’s alternative ethical?arrow_forward
- When we talk about ethics, what precisely do we understand by that term? Is it possible that claim rights, which are examples of positive rights, and freedoms, which are examples of negative rights, may ever find themselves in a situation in which they directly contradict one another?arrow_forwardUtilitarianism is a set of ethical principles that focuses on individual consequences of an action. a. True b. Falsearrow_forwardIn what ways may we anticipate seeing the framework for ethical reasoning employed in the workplace in the years to come?arrow_forward
- Principles of Information Systems (MindTap Course...Computer ScienceISBN:9781305971776Author:Ralph Stair, George ReynoldsPublisher:Cengage Learning