preview

Is Forgiving Student Loan Debt A Good Idea Summary

Decent Essays

In her essay “Is Forgiving Student Loan Debt a Good Idea,” Kayla Webley argues that forgiving debt could be a bad idea. Her article was exceptionally influential in demonstrating the way that the payment would put the nation in a bad position. It would send the wrong message to individuals who attended a university and the individuals who didn’t. Webley touched on Robert Applebaum’s petition to provide a one-time bailout of student loan debt. Applebaum constructs his article in light of his own plan and utilizes his own particular figures and "actualities." He talks about the simplest proposal “provide a one-time bailout of student loan debt” (130). He thinks by taking the burden away from people in debt will improve the housing market as …show more content…

He gives the scenario, “someone who has $50,000 in debt forgiven isn’t likely to pump all those dollars back into the economy in short amount of time” (130). Wolfer thinks a more effective stimulus would be to give a certain amount of poor people at least $1,000 because it would most definitely be spent.
Webley’s argument seems valid against Applebaum petition because she is able to give several great ways to why this would turn out to be a bad idea. She states that most borrowers can afford to pay off their loans but at the same time there are others who need the relief of not paying it back. She makes the point about taxpayers footing the bill for borrowers’ education, future generations, and the possibility of people just taking loans out praying for a bailout. She asked the question “why should taxpayers–especially those who never attended college in the first place–foot the bill for the borrowers?” (131).
She believes Applebaum’s plan is only a temporary fix to an ongoing problem within our education system. Webley states, “but perhaps the biggest roadblock to Applebaum’s plan is that a one-time bailout is temporary fix to an ongoing problem” (131). In order to fix this problem, Webley relates to a look at how higher education in the United States is

Get Access